If you have ever watched the famous HGTV show Fixer to Fabulous, then you must already be familiar with Dave and Jenny Marrs, right? Well, in that show, they renovate homes and hand them over to the new owners after the final product looks just beautiful space and outright stunning. But this passion of theirs has led them into some legal trouble, and yes, we’re talking about the lawsuit against them, but recently we saw the HGTV Stars Lawsuit Settlement, so let’s talk about it a little more.
First Of All, How Did the Lawsuit Start?
Well, it actually goes back to May 2022, when a couple named Mathew and Sarah McGrath from Bentonville, Arkansas, went ahead and approached the Marrs family to buy a house from them. Like, as per the deal, the couple agreed to pay about $559,000 for the home and even paid $15,000 upfront.
The deal wasn’t done yet, you see, the couple actually requested a few upgrades before that, like a better kitchen sink, stairs for the back deck, upgraded garage windows, wooden floor for the bedrooms and things like that. And all these additional upgrades were about $10,000 costly.
Well, in the end, the deal was done, and the closing date for the house was August 2022. All good, right? Not exactly, you see, when the McGraths showed up to their new house, none of the upgrades were made, but that was just the start, because they were literally noticing dozens and dozens of other problems with the property.
What the Couple Claimed
Well, as per the McGraths, this was a breach of contract, like the Marrs’ didn’t deliver on what they promised initially. And these weren’t just made-up things, you see, later, a professional checked out the house and found a bunch of problems.
Just to give you perspective on how bad things were, like, the driveway and walkway needed major repairs that still would cost nearly $39,000. Then there were landscaping issues with the property as well, so add another $48,000 to that. One of the scariest ones? The back deck wasn’t properly attached, which in itself is a huge safety risk, especially if there are kids who will be living in this house.
McGraths Then Took This Matter To The Court
Finally, in February 2023, we saw the McGraths take this matter to the court and sue Dave and Jenny Marrs’ companies. From the looks of it and as per the details that are already out, well, the case was set to go to trial in September 2024, but it got delayed and moved to January 27, 2025.
Then? Oh, then we saw this HGTV Stars Lawsuit Settlement come to light, like both parties got together silently outside the court and decided to settle it out without involving the court. So, since all of this was just private, we don’t know what went down and how much settlement money was paid, but right now, this case is dismissed. Similar to the Elon Musk OpenAI For-Profit Lawsuit, where high-profile individuals are facing legal pushback over perceived betrayals of mission or agreement, this case also highlights how trust and expectations can quickly turn into court battles.
Related Articles :
- Elon Musk OpenAI For-Profit Lawsuit
- DOGE Treasury Payment Lawsuit
- Carrie Underwood The View Lawsuit
- Cam Skattebo Lawsuit
Read related cases in our Other Major Lawsuits & Disputes section.
