Understanding the Humana Stars Lawsuit
Humana, one of the largest Medicare Advantage insurers in the U.S., is now at the center of a legal storm involving allegations of fraudulent Medicare star ratings. The Humana Stars lawsuit has serious implications for both taxpayers and Medicare recipients. At its core, the case centers around accusations that Humana manipulated data to boost its Medicare Advantage star ratings, allowing the company to receive higher federal reimbursements.
For affected consumers and whistleblowers, this lawsuit isn’t just about corporate misconduct—it’s about holding one of the country’s most influential healthcare insurers accountable. If you or a loved one were enrolled in a Humana Medicare Advantage plan, you may want to know how this lawsuit could impact you and what legal recourse you may have.
Background: What Triggered the Humana Stars Lawsuit?
The trouble began with whistleblower complaints and audits that suggested Humana might be inflating patient health data to boost the “star ratings” of its Medicare Advantage plans. These star ratings, issued by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), are crucial in determining how much federal funding insurers receive. The higher the rating, the more money a plan gets.
According to the complaint, Humana allegedly:
- Submitted inaccurate diagnostic codes to CMS
- Exaggerated the health risks of enrollees
- Used these inflated codes to increase its CMS star ratings
- Improperly obtained bonus payments from the government
In 2021 and 2022, federal investigations and audits began focusing on Humana’s coding practices. This resulted in further scrutiny from the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) and sparked lawsuits under the False Claims Act (FCA).
Legal Claims: What Are Plaintiffs Alleging?
The lawsuits primarily revolve around the False Claims Act, a federal law that imposes liability on companies that defraud governmental programs. Here’s a breakdown of the legal claims:
1. False Claims Act Violations
Whistleblowers allege that Humana knowingly submitted false risk adjustment data to CMS. This directly resulted in inflated Medicare reimbursements.
2. Medicare Fraud
By artificially raising its star ratings through inaccurate data, Humana may have committed Medicare fraud, costing taxpayers billions of dollars.
3. Unjust Enrichment
The lawsuits also claim that Humana profited from government funds it was not entitled to, leading to unjust enrichment at the expense of taxpayers and honest competitors.
4. Retaliation Against Whistleblowers
Some filings allege that Humana retaliated against employees who raised concerns about its data practices, which is also a violation of the False Claims Act.
Eligibility: Who Can Join or File a Lawsuit?
Although much of the litigation is being brought forward by whistleblowers and the DOJ, consumers enrolled in Humana’s Medicare Advantage plans may also have valid claims. Here’s who might be eligible:
- Individuals who were misled about the quality or benefits of Humana Medicare Advantage plans based on inflated star ratings
- Former Humana employees who were retaliated against for reporting internal fraud
- Medical providers whose patient data was used inaccurately or without consent
Time limits for filing vary depending on the type of claim. False Claims Act cases usually have a statute of limitations ranging from 6 to 10 years. It’s critical to consult with a legal professional promptly to preserve your rights.
Current Legal Status: Updates on the Humana Lawsuit
As of 2025, multiple legal actions against Humana are pending. While no Multi-District Litigation (MDL) has been formed yet, the Department of Justice continues to investigate. Humana has denied any wrongdoing, but the DOJ’s increasing focus suggests that a significant settlement or court ruling could be on the horizon.
Notably, some reports indicate that Humana could be facing billions of dollars in penalties if found liable under the False Claims Act. The case could follow the path of similar lawsuits filed against other Medicare Advantage insurers like UnitedHealth and Anthem, which resulted in major settlements.
How to File a Claim: Steps to Take If You’re Affected
If you suspect you’ve been harmed due to Humana’s alleged misconduct, you have options. Here’s a basic roadmap:
1. Consult a Healthcare Fraud Attorney
Contact a lawyer who specializes in Medicare fraud or mass torts. They can help assess whether your situation qualifies for legal action. Many law firms offer free consultations.
2. Gather Documentation
Helpful records may include:
- Your Medicare Advantage plan documents
- Communications from Humana about your plan
- Evidence of being misled by the star ratings
3. Understand Contingency Fees
Most mass tort attorneys work on a contingency basis, meaning you pay nothing upfront. Legal fees are only collected if your case wins or settles.
4. Whistleblower Protections
If you’re a former employee or insider, you may qualify for whistleblower protections and even a portion of any recovered funds under the False Claims Act.
FAQs About the Humana Stars Lawsuit
1. What are Medicare star ratings and why do they matter?
Medicare star ratings, issued by CMS, reflect the quality of care and service in Medicare Advantage plans. Higher ratings result in larger bonus payments from the government. Manipulating these ratings can amount to fraud.
2. Can I still file a lawsuit if I no longer have a Humana plan?
Yes. If you were enrolled in a Humana Medicare Advantage plan during the period in question and can show harm or deception, you may still be eligible to file a claim.
3. What is the False Claims Act and how does it relate to this case?
The False Claims Act allows private individuals (whistleblowers) to file lawsuits on behalf of the government against entities that defraud federal programs. This law is central to the Humana Stars lawsuit.
Relevant U.S. Laws and Regulations
Key laws that play a role in this case include:
- False Claims Act (31 U.S.C. §§ 3729 – 3733)
- Medicare Advantage Regulations under CMS
- Whistleblower Protection Act
These laws are designed to prevent fraud and ensure that government healthcare programs operate with integrity. If violations are proven, the penalties can be severe—including triple damages and civil fines.
Conclusion: Take Action If You’ve Been Affected
The Humana Stars lawsuit is not just another legal battle—it represents a pivotal moment in the fight for transparency and accountability in Medicare Advantage programs. Whether you’re a consumer who feels misled or a whistleblower with inside information, this lawsuit offers a legal pathway to seek justice.
If you believe you’ve been affected by Humana’s alleged misconduct, don’t wait. Consult an experienced legal professional to discuss your options and protect your rights.
Related Reading: For more insight into high-profile legal cases, read about the molly qerim lawsuit and how it’s impacting public awareness around media-related litigation.
Read related cases in our Other Major Lawsuits & Disputes section.
